I used to have quite an aversion to exercise. Though I’ve long admired people who are fit and have the discipline to stick to exercise, I’ve always dipped in and out of any kind of routine. For a term in my last year of high school I swam laps every day after school. I had broken up with a boyfriend and I needed to move on from all that dramatic heartbreak. When I felt better, I stopped swimming.
Another time when I kept with a routine for more than a week, was when I decided to pay myself $1 per 1 km that I walked or cycled. I could get a lot more kms on the bike so I biked more than I walked! My motivation was to try to stick to an exercise routine and I thought that by setting myself a goal of being able to buy something I wanted and saving for it, I would kill two birds with one stone, so to say. And it worked for a number of months. Until I didn’t have a new object of desire to work towards that was motivating me enough to stick to it. End of that plan.
When I read the book, “No Sweat” by Michelle Segar, PhD, who is a sustainable change coach, it got me thinking about what it means to exercise and why I might feel so resistant to something I know to be good for me and what might motivate me to stick at it.
Michelle Segar is a researcher at the University of Michigan with a focus on how people can create sustainable motivation for physical activity and other self-care behaviours. Her ideas about what motivates us to exercise and what counts as exercise was quite a revelation for me. Here is an evidence based, well researched approach to exercise that she had used when working with thousands of people that says that everything we do, counts!
Walking to the train, walking around the corner to a friends, walking to the clothes line and carrying a full load of washing, gardening, carrying around little children, lugging grocery bags, de-stressing by dancing to your favourite music, getting up from your desk each hour, a bike ride with friends, roller derby, whatever you enjoy doing and for however long you enjoy doing it all counts. The key is to choose things you enjoy doing and do them for that reason alone.
A good example is my husband. For as long as I have known him, and for years before, he has gotten everywhere he needs to go by train and bike. Some days he will bike 30kms and stop somewhere for a cold swim, doing laps against the current. But if you dressed him in lycra, put him on a road bike and then threw him in the sea all in the pursuit of a duathlon his smile would head south and he’d be walking in the opposite direction. Same activities, different motivation, different needs met.
Of course, Michelle says, if you enjoy structured exercise like the gym or team sports and it works for you, keep at it, wonderful! And of course, there are healthy recommendations to aim for, but to enjoy moving and to stick to it, is a great starting place for folks like me who, for some reason, have a difficult or stop-start relationship with exercise. The idea that ‘everything counts’, is a great relief.
I feel pretty sure my aversion to ‘exercise’ came from my early school years. When I was between the ages of 5 and 8 I had chronic bouts of tonsillitis, likely a milk allergy but no one talked about food intolerances or allergies much in the 70’s and early 80’s. When I wasn’t sick and could make it to school, though I was a pretty normal ‘kid’ size, I felt like a heavy lump. My little body just didn’t seem able to flick my legs over the gym bar in the graceful, light and effortless moves my friends could do. I came to dread outdoor time at school, team sports, playground shenanigans, and more than anything running.
I felt ashamed and uncomfortable about how poorly I seemed to be able to ‘perform’ everyday kid movements. I decided I was not a sporty kind of girl. Though I couldn’t avoid PE, team sports, cross country – a punishment and a humiliation – I never stopped dreading it.
As I got older I knew that ‘exercise’ was something one should do to be healthy and being healthy was something I kept moving towards. There are lots of ways to start with health and for me it was food, cooking and nutrition. As I learnt more about holistic health I understood that exercise is one of the pillars of health, so it was never off my list of goals, it was just always at the bottom! I felt no positive feelings towards it and I had no idea how to make myself do it, day after day.
I would make the resolution to get fit each new year but because I hadn’t made any connection to why I both felt I needed to exercise yet simultaneously feel zero physical urge to do it, I wouldn’t last for long. Will power and resolution just doesn’t get you very far.
What really made a shift was when I changed the wording – from exercise to movement. When I reflected on my 30’s, I was studying full time in Wellington which meant a bike to the train, a quick walk from the station to school and in reverse at the end of the day, a large garden to create, maintain, tend in the weekends (walking up and down the garden looking for my misplaced Ngashi tool) I would go to bed late after doing all the home stuff: cooking, after school run around, groceries, washing, the juggle, I barely sat still. I was really active, I moved constantly and in different ways, I was actually quite fit! Though in my mind none of that counted as exercise. I felt guilty that I wasn’t fitting in a decent length of a walk, I wasn’t doing any structured exercise.
I now see a personal trainer once a week and go to a HIIT class once a week. Two things I never imagined doing but they work for me. I like having a PT who keeps me moving forward and who has a plan for me. I also like the group class with other women.
Now that I have a better understanding about my relationship and beliefs around exercise I am making headway. I also understand that a mix of things works well for me. Feeling guilty about not exercising is a burden I am happy to put down!
I may not run 10 kms but I will walk up a mountain and down with my husband to be out in the bush, away from the city, to be together. I may never feel motivated to do the same exercises in the garage or lounge on my own but finding people who can do them with me really helps. Other needs are met and exercise is the bonus.
Knowing what we like to do and letting go of the ideas of what we should be doing to exercise, is the key. Choosing ways to move that you enjoy makes all the difference in your motivation to move.
“Developing an awareness of how you really feel (when you’re moving) versus how you think you should feel and learning how to act on that genuine feeling, in the moment, puts you in charge of the decision (of how you want to move).”
— Michelle Segar
I can highly recommend Michelle’s book if being active and moving is important to you. You can listen to it on Spotify too! Listening to podcasts and books while I walk, great motivator!!
Here’s one of the small bursts I have come to add into my day: Wim Hof’s 11 minute breathing routine.